Eye Candy Bake Shop

Katie Graham 2 months ago

I’m so thankful to my best friend for introducing me to Eye Candy! I’ve been to so many gluten free bakeries and hands down this is the best. Everything I’ve tried is incredible and honestly tastes even better than gluten desserts I used to eat. They have such a wide variety of options, from cookies to eclairs, cheesecake, donuts, tiramisu, cinnamon rolls, and so much more. The owner and her family are so kind and friendly, and they were such a pleasure to work with for my custom birthday cake. The topper looked exactly like my puppy and exceeded my expectations. Your next treat is waiting at Eye Candy in Geneva! Don’t miss out!!

Linda Mielnicki 3 months ago

Eye Candy saved me when another bakery told me they couldn’t make my baby shower cake. They designed an absolutely gorgeous cake and it was gluten free and vegan AND delicious!!! Our guests ate every last bite of it and wanted more! Nobody even knew it was free from gluten or dairy lol! They are the kindest people and true artists! I will definitely order again. And if you haven’t stopped by to eat their little daily treats, you are missing out. Delish. Especially the chocolate lava fudgy thing it’s the bomb!

Relm 4 months ago

Eye Candy Bakery is a community gem. As a man with gluten sensitivities, this is an absolute treasure. The sheer wealth of options, all beautiful and delicious, have me and my partner coming back week after week. I find anyway I can to legitimize coming back. Their cheesecakes are PHENOMENAL Eclairs PHENOMENAL palettes PHENOMENAL Oh, and in ADDITION to the amazing desserts, the staff is just as sweet. Even when business is busy they make time to connect while working. Love this place.

Julia Maz 5 months ago

After being a consistent customer for years, this past weekend I placed a custom order for cupcakes that were shark themed. There were 40 cupcakes and about three boxes - my father picked them up and all the cupcakes were okay except for one big box (photo attached). The fins were broken. I contacted Eye Candy after the event to show the box that was broken. They blamed my father’s one block drive for the damage because they measured the boxes would be big enough for the fins. If that was the case, wouldn’t they all be okay? I found the order placement process difficult to do with the back and forth emails as I tried to lock down the contract. I requested a pick up at 1pm and they could only accommodate 12:45pm… what is 15 minutes?! Overall, after all this, the cupcakes were disappointing compared to other baked goods we have had. They were dry, fell apart, and nobody raved about them as I expected they would. I will not be ordering again from Eye Candy.

Sarah Spencer a year ago

I am impressed! Gluten free baked goods are very hit or miss, and this is the biggest hit I’ve had to date. The seating along the stairs creates a beautiful little spot to eat, and the patrons and staff are all friendly. There were so many options for a wide variety of dietary needs and flavor preferences, even hours after opening on a busy Saturday. I will definitely be back!